Close this search box.
Chalk drawing of house on a concrete wall

Opinion: Homeless shelters that make sense: Large, dangerous congregate shelters drive people away

By Deborah Berkman and Josiah Haken
New York Daily News

The number of New Yorkers experiencing homelessness has reached levels not seen since the Great Depression. While a robust shelter system is an important part of the emergency response to any homelessness crisis, New York City’s shelter system is complex and troubled. It mostly houses single adults in common congregate environments, with multiple cots in a room and shared living spaces. As a result, thousands sleep on the street, in subways, and in public spaces because these environments feel safer than shelters. While this may feel like a nuisance to New Yorkers who are housed, we have left our neighbors with few viable alternatives.

The vast majority of people sleeping outside do so as a result of significant trauma that has occurred in their lives or that they personally experienced or witnessed within New York City’s congregate shelters: from being assaulted, witnessing gang violence, being threatened, and being robbed, to being forced to fight or sell drugs on behalf of others in exchange for safety.

Share this post

Related Articles

Documented: Number of Unrepresented People in NYC Immigration Courts Marks 18-Year High

In a recent interview with DocumentedNY, Allison Cutler, supervising attorney in NYLAG’s Immigrant Protection Unit overseeing the Pro Se Plus Project (PSPP), provided insight into the pressing issue of the lack of representation and legal challenges confronting our new neighbors. In response to this need, NYLAG and partner organizations created Pro Se Plus Project (PSPP).

Read More »

Testimony: The Intersecting Insecurities of Hunger and Housing Instability

Graham Horn, Staff Attorney in the Shelter Advocacy Initiative and the Public Assistance and SNAP Project at NYLAG testified in support of four bills, which would encourage the United States Congress to pass and the President to sign vital reforms to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, an expanded Child Tax Credit, and a renewed Farm Bill with increased funding for life-saving food aid — all of which could contribute to improving health outcomes for our clients.

Read More »
Scroll to Top